The reading group reads the Groundlines of the Philosophy of Right. As interest arises, we also read other texts by Hegel in between – as an excursus. They are provided here for reading along, especially for those who do not have the books at hand or do not want to buy them specially.
The texts are in the public domain. Each web page of an excursus contains exactly one printed page of the edition given; the page number stands at the top in square brackets and in the text between vertical bars. This makes it easy to agree in discussion on where one is, and every passage can be found again in one’s own copy. The Encyclopaedia is cited by paragraphs; it therefore stands on a single page. Where an excursus touches on the Groundlines, this is linked on the spot as a cross-reference. The English translations are our own; texts not yet translated are linked to the German version.
Highlighting and notes: Select a passage with the mouse or your finger and tap “Highlight” or “Note”. This works on every page of the website, including the Groundlines. Your highlights are stored only in your own browser; under “My notes” at the bottom right you can see them all at a glance, save them as a file (Export) and load them again on another device (Import). For those who prefer to read on paper: each text has a PDF print version with a wide margin for notes.
Hegel’s Philosophy of Religion
Depending on whether one wants to explore the fully developed system of the mature Hegel or the path of thought of the young Hegel, two approaches suggest themselves.
A. The mature philosophy of religion
Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion, Part I: The Concept of Religion
Werkausgabe vol. 16, pp. 91–247; together with the Introduction (pp. 11–88) (PDF (German)) · PDF (German)
Hegel’s fundamental unfolding of religious consciousness: the relation of finite spirit to absolute spirit and the distinction between the forms of feeling, representation – the peculiar form of religion – and comprehending thought, the form of philosophy. At the end stands the relation of religion to the state, the counterpart to the Remark to § 270 of the Groundlines.
The best overall introduction. As lectures, more oral, more fluent and more intelligible than the printed works. The text is the compilation of the edition of the Association of Friends from Hegel’s manuscript and transcripts of several years, not a single transcript.
Encyclopaedia of the Philosophical Sciences, §§ 553–571: Absolute Spirit – currently in the reading group
Encyclopaedia, 3rd edition 1830; with the concluding §§ 572–577 · PDF (German)
The compressed placing of religion in the late system: religion as the second sphere of absolute spirit, after art and before philosophy. §§ 564–571 treat the revealed religion.
The highest systematic condensation – ideal for a few sessions in which one works out, sentence by sentence, the logic of the late version of the system.
Phenomenology of Spirit, Chapter VII.C: The Revealed Religion
Werkausgabe vol. 3, pp. 545–574 · PDF (German)
The phenomenological passage of 1807: the transition from the ancient religion of art to the revealed religion, Trinity and Incarnation in the representation of the community, before the turn into absolute knowing.
Linguistically tremendous and central to its reception, but conceptually extraordinarily dense.
B. The “Early Theological Writings”
The Life of Jesus (1795) – currently in the reading group
Gesammelte Werke vol. 1, pp. 207–278 · PDF (German)
A paraphrase of the Gospels in the spirit of Kantian philosophy and the Enlightenment: Jesus as a teacher of virtue who proclaims the moral law and turns against merely “positive”, statutory law.
A fascinating glimpse of the young, Kantian Hegel. Only partly representative of the mature dialectic – the late Hegel sharply criticized mere moralism (cf. § 135).
The Positivity of the Christian Religion (1795/96)
Werkausgabe vol. 1, pp. 104–229 · PDF (German)
How could Jesus’ original teaching of freedom turn into an authoritarian, dogmatic church institution?
Strongly critical of institutions and of the church; a bridge from the moral to the social and legal philosophy of the young Hegel. Here are found the most connections with the Groundlines: church and state, contract, community of goods, equality.
The Spirit of Christianity and Its Fate (1798–1800)
Werkausgabe vol. 1, pp. 274–418 · PDF (German)
Hegel’s overcoming of Kantianism in Frankfurt. Love takes the place of law and duty as the overcoming of division; for the first time the basic structures of the later dialectic appear – division, reconciliation, sublation.
The philosophically deepest of the early writings. Whoever wants to see how Hegel’s dialectic grew out of his engagement with religion will find the most exciting text here.
Also on this website
The Oldest System-Programme of German Idealism (in German) · The Natural Right Essay · FAQs: Was Hegel a Christian, a pantheist or an atheist? · What do Christians get from Hegel? · Where does Hegel stand on Judaism? · Is the state God for Hegel?
