[p. 222]
|222| nevertheless human enough to ask afterwards how it can then be explained that such an edifice, so contrary to human reason and error through and through, could have been erected. One lets church history show how, on simple truths that lay at the ground, such a heap of errors was gradually piled up through passion and ignorance, that in this gradual determination of the individual dogmas, continued through centuries, the holy fathers were not always guided by knowledge, moderation and reason, that even at the adoption of the Christian religion not merely pure love of truth but in part very composite motives, very unholy considerations, impure passions and needs of the spirit often stemming only from superstition were at work, that in general outward circumstances alien to religion, selfish intentions, force and cunning modelled the faith of the nations according to their ends. But this way of explaining presupposes a deep contempt for man, a glaring superstition about his understanding; and it leaves the main question untouched, namely to show the appropriateness of religion to nature as nature was modified in different centuries; in other words, one asked about the truth of religion in connection with the customs and character of peoples and times, and the answer is that it was sheer superstition, deceit and stupidity. Most is blamed on sensibility; it must have caused everything; but however much dominion one may ascribe to it, man does not thereby cease to be a rational being, or his nature always necessarily has higher needs of religiosity, and the way in which he satisfies them, i.e. the system of his faith, his worship, his duties, cannot have been sheer stupidity, nor such impure stupidity as left room for all immorality.
In stating as the purpose of this treatise that it is not to investigate whether Christianity contains doctrines that are positive, but whether it is a positive religion at all, these two views can fall into one insofar as even the assertion that the Christian religion is positive or not, with all the consequences flowing from it, could enter into religious doctrine itself, and thus the positivity of a single doctrine would really be investigated. Admittedly every view of the whole can itself again be isolated and placed beside the rest, and thus made into a part; but the content of this view will always concern the whole. Further, as mentioned above, the question of positivity
