[p. 187]
|187| the executive power needed for this, to fix, command and produce the disposition, the motives of actions, and with the impossibility of governing human freedom through these means and of producing more than legality, there had to be from time to time – or else the church would have had to be able to bring it about that it irretrievably extinguished the character of humanity in a part of the human race, made this lack into an ineradicable character of a race -, there had to be from time to time men who did not find the demands of their own heart satisfied in this ecclesiastical legality, in a character such as ascetics is capable of forming, and felt themselves capable of giving themselves a law of morality that would proceed from freedom9); if they did not keep their faith to themselves alone, they became founders of a sect, which, in case it was not suppressed by the church, spread and, the further it rolled on from its source, again kept only the rules and laws of its founder, which for its adherents were now no longer laws from freedom either, but again ecclesiastical statutes; which again brought about the origin of new sects; and so on and on – first in the Jewish church; from it the Christian sect arose; it became a church; in the bosom of this church new sects were again produced, which then also grew into churches; and so it must go on as long as the state fails to recognize the extent of its rights and either lets a state of a dominant church arise within itself or even associates itself with it and so again oversteps its powers. –10)The fundamental error that underlies the whole system of a church is the failure to recognize the rights of every capacity of the human spirit, especially of the first among them, reason; and if this
9) Werkausgabe: Beguines in Mosheim [Institutiones historiae ecclesiasticae saec. XIII, p. II, c. V, § 9, 10]
10) Werkausgabe: [in the margin:] 29. April 96.
