[p. 168]
|168| the rights springing from it and bound to it should have fallen away with it.
And if, e.g., Catholics had still remained in such a reformed country, could the same dues still rightly be demanded of them, – could the state rightly demand them? To it they pay other dues, as citizens; these ecclesiastical dues were never its own. – The new church? They can rightly assert that they are obligated only to the old one – and also may contribute nothing to the new one, since they do not belong to it. The similar case occurs in many Catholic, e.g. the Austrian, countries, and has caused many disputes and embarrassments especially since Joseph’s edicts of toleration. – Are the non-Catholics bound still to pay the same dues they previously paid to the church, the same fees for baptism, confession money, maintenance of the various requisites of Catholic worship, as they were obligated until now? No, say the Protestants, for they do not belong to the Catholic church, and what they paid, they paid to the church. Yes, say the Catholics, they still owe this parish, this monastery the same as before, let them belong to whatever church they please. Here the Protestants argue from the reverse of the principles their church asserts against its members, and the Catholics from the same principles that the Protestant church has on its lips within itself.
The same inconveniences arise when a church makes contracts with other states as a church that has a definite faith; if as such it wants to make something a duty for the other contracting party, it has likewise bound this duty to something it has the right to change, while at the same time it demands that the duty of the other shall remain the same. Thus the Protestants bought with much blood the freedom of their faith and worship in accordance with the imperial constitution – but
