[p. 190]
|190| that he be subject to such an alien code, then the whole power of the church is illegitimate; and no man can renounce the right to give himself his law, to owe account for its administration to himself alone, for with this alienation he would cease to be a man. But to prevent him from doing so is not the business of the state – this would mean wanting to compel man to be man, and would be force. – The origin of all sects in the Christian church in the middle and modern ages was grounded on the feeling of individual men of having the right to be their own legislators; but, born in barbarous times or in a class of the people condemned to crudeness by its rulers, the principle of such a legislation was usually a heated, wild and disorderly fantasy, among whose products a fine spark of reason sometimes flashed out, and in which the inalienable human right to give oneself laws from one’s own breast was nevertheless always asserted.12)
12) Werkausgabe: In the MS an empty page follows.
[Additions]
1.
13)A positive faith is such a system of religious propositions as is supposed to have truth for us because it is commanded us by an authority to which we cannot refuse to subject our faith. In this concept there occurs first a system of religious propositions or truths which, independently of our holding them true, are supposed to be regarded as truths, which, even if they had never been known to any man, never held true by any man, would still remain truths, and which insofar are frequently called objective
13) Werkausgabe: Nohl pp. 233-39; Schüler no. 54 (winter 1795/96)
